McAfee UTILITIES 4.0 Instrukcja Użytkownika Pobierz pdf (Strona 5)

Appeal 2009-012273

Application 101635,397

Claims 11 and 24 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C.

103(a) as

unpatentable over McAfee, Disk Space, Disk Cleanup, and Error Codes.

ISSUES

The issue of obviousness turns primarily on whether it was predictable to

operate various housekeeping utilities for disk space conservation and

backup on a server as well as on stand alone or client computers. The issue

also turns on predictability of automating a known process and whether file

compression reduces the size of log files.

FACTS PERTINENT TO THE ISSUES

The following enumerated Findings of Fact (FF) are believed to be

supported by a preponderance of the evidence.

Facts Related to the Prior Art

McAfee

01. McAfee is a software utilities user guide. McAfee Cover.

02. McAfee deletes and compresses those types of files one

specifies. McAfee 33.

03. McAfee's utilities can be placed on a server in a client server

network environment. McAfee iii.

Disk Space

04. Disk Space is directed to a Microsoft Disk Cleanup Wizard

utility that starts automatically when a user responds to an

automatically created Low Disk Space prompt when disk space

runs low. Disk Space 1.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Brak uwag

McAfee UTILITIES 4.0 Instrukcja Użytkownika Strona 5